Virtual Heritage and Engaged Audiences: a Challenging Relationship
When Ruth Tringham, Professor of the Graduate School (Anthropology) at UC Berkeley and CoDA’s President, was invited to address the final keynote at the conference “Modeling Culture: 3D Archaeology and the Future of the Past” organized by UC Santa Cruz in April, she was in a bit of a crisis. Although a total pioneer in the experimentation of all new technologies and creative remix of archaeological data and virtual worlds, Ruth was never a big believer in – or practitioner of 3D modeling and virtual archaeology. Or better said, not a convinced supporter of the way 3D modeling and virtuality are conceived and used today in archaeology and cultural heritage in general. Of course, the crisis passed quickly, and Ruth took this opportunity to formulate deeper thoughts on a constructive critique of 3D modeling and virtuality today, and come up with her own “theory of change”, which she shares with us in the slideshow below.
In her presentation “Prowess-ing the Past: Considering the Audience”, Ruth gives a thorough analysis of state of the art, best practices, and successful (or not) case studies, and shares a new audience-centric point of view.
Above all, she shifts the focus from 3D modeling in archaeology and cultural heritage to consider the ways in which a more active motivation and engagement of users (whether professionals or general public) might also lead to the long-term sustainability of the models and visualizations. She presents a strong argument to evaluate the impact and engagement of 3D models, not so much based on how many users visit a model once, but on the duration of the visit and even better, the number of re-visits and frequency of enjoyment.
Ruth asks a number of questions (that we consider the right questions!) that are all aimed at the overarching goal of her exploration: what is it that engages or might engage users in the VR model or other digital visualization product? Why do we frequently revisit an amusement park or the zoo, but rarely a VR installation? What is it that might motivate revisitation and re-use of in-place and online installations? Ruth highlights for us a number of interconnected aspects that would lead in her opinion to greater audience engagement with installations and models involving 3D visualizations of the past: Participation, Exploration, Cultural Presence, Education of Attention, and Multisensorial Experience. Enjoy the slideshow and send us your feedback or links if you know of projects and initiatives that can feed into these reflections.
Cover Image: Kelley Shanahan
Author: Cinzia Perlingieri
Slideshow: Ruth Tringham, images credited separately
Due to the heavy rainfall this winter, California State and National Parks and Heritage Sites are under threat of serious structural damage, mud slides and land erosion. The Ghost Town of Bodie is among these.read more
Freelancer Developers can be an affordable option for small teams or projects with a tight budget. CoDA tested out Upwork, an online hiring platform, last year and worked with a few freelancers, some better than others! Here are 5 things we learned and how you can get the most for your project on a budget of any size.read more
Three organizations team up to explore possibilities for international exchange and increase impact of world heritage and archaeology. Great news! These three organizations have started a collaboration through a Memorandum of Understanding to establish a cooperative...read more
For the ancient Polynesians, folklore was shared by word of mouth, today the most popular platform for telling stories are movies. Moana, Walt Disney Studios’ latest film, tells the story of a young girl raised to become chief of her people who comes to discover she...read more
The Hawaiian people built a rock enclosure in a shallow depression in a volcanic ridge in the mountains above Kapolei, in an area now known as Pālehua.read more
This course is a cross-disciplinary exploration of Cultural Heritage on a global and local scale through discussion, debate, in-class activities and team-based research projects.read more
Six Fundraising Lessons from the world most successful fundraisers at the 2016 “Nonprofit Fundraising Masters” event in San Franciscoread more
Looking back on the process, Kodak PCD conversion almost seems easy. If you are at the beginning of your zip recuperation journey, these steps may not be obvious, but they are very doable. The only solution available which will keep images high-resolution, convert and maintain original metadata, and save you a LOT of working hours is PCD Magic!read more
At the Lowest Place on Earth, on the South-East shores of the Dead Sea, nestled in the Ghor es-Safi and a short turn off the Dead Sea highway, you’ll find a little museum with a big mission and big stories to tell.read more
The Lifeways of Ancient Africans offers an overview of the archaeological heritage of Africa, from the emergence of modern humans to the beginnings of European colonization.read more